 | Harold Fredrik Cherniss - 1977 - 596 sivua
...do participate in Unity. quoted by Vlastos and to the doctrine of ideas generally, this is to say: " the idea of x is x " means " the idea of x and x are...therefore the idea of x does not 'have the character x.'" Since Plato formulates this distinction in the second part of the Parmenides, it is reasonable to suppose... | |
 | Simo Knuuttila, Jaakko Hintikka - 1985 - 326 sivua
...'beautiful' are identical"'. In general, he believes, " 'the idea of x is x' means 'the idea of AT and x are identical and therefore the idea of x does not "have the character x'"". 16 Although Cherniss does not say so explicitly, this analysis would presumably lead to the conclusion... | |
 | Nicholas D. Smith - 1998 - 370 sivua
...applied to the statements quoted by Vlastos and to the doctrine of ideas generally, this is to say: "the idea of x is x" means "the idea of x and x are...therefore the idea of x does not 'have the character x."Since Plato formulates this distinction in the second part of the Parmenides, it is reasonable to... | |
| |
Parmenides also, eg at 142b 7-c 2, doctrine of ideas generally, this is to say: 'the idea of x is x' means 'the idea of x and x are identical and therefore the idea of x does not "have the character x... 